Washington consensus initiative for policy dialogue. Africa and the washington consensus finding the right path. But at the same time, and despite the fierce critique, many methodological aspects and policy implications of the postwashington consensus do not seem to depart so far from the previous mainstream. Washington consensus emerged no sooner than it had been formulated, in the realm of ideas and from outcomes on the ground. A short history of the washington consensus 14 john williamson 3. Democracy and the washington consensus john williamson institute for international economics, washington, dc summary.
The socalled washington consensus, which dictated most of the solutions proposed by international financial organizations, began to be questioned when a large number of emerging economies reduced their reliance on multilateral debt. The rise and fall of the washington consensus by charles gore. This paper argues that there is a substantial body of economic advice, roughly summarized in the washington consensus, that deserves to be endorsed across the political spectrum. The old, unilateral style would almost certainly have achieved less. Jul 19, 2017 the beijing consensus could become an alternative to angloamerican neoliberalism, presented by some in the west as a onesizefitall model for all developing countries. The strange history of the washington consensus 199 tated a limitation of its content to what was capable of commanding a consensus, so if something was not already consensual, it did not make it to the agenda, even if i personally thought it was desirable and important. Washington consensus politics in latin american context. What the crisis did, however, was to underscore the instability inherent in capitalist systems even ones as developed and sophisticated as the united states. First, i will provide a brief background discussion to set the interview in context. Pdf the term washington consensus, as williamson conceived it.
The evolution of the antiwashington consensus debate. The post washington consensus goes further in detailing the nature of the failures of the washington consensus. These policies, involving trade liberalization and privatization among other measures. The washington consensus as i originally formulated it was not written as a policy prescription for development. Washington consensus world bank documents world bank group. Other articles where postwashington consensus is discussed. This article analyzes the birth, evolution, implications, and controversy surrounding williamsons decalogue from a latin american standpoint. Creditor countnes, specifically the g7, dominate the imf.
Growth, openness, and the great liberalization, 1970s2000s antoni estevadeordal, alan m. In the countries that followed washington consensus policies, economic. The post washington consensus is critical of the washington consensus and is much more explicit on poverty and distribution concerns, the importance of the quality of institutions and governance, the role of the state however, the theory of good institutions and good governance and the view. In recent times, the imf, however, has changed its position on promoting full capital account liberalization. The author is indebted to colleagues at the institute for international. Washington consensus, particularly that of unalloyed reliance on foreign capital. The challenge then is to incorporate a broader range of the views of the developing countrtes and the borrower countrtes. Washington consensus definition and criticism economics help. The postwashington consensus is critical of the washington consensus and is much more explicit on poverty and distribution concerns, the importance of the quality of institutions and governance, the role of the state however, the theory of good institutions and good governance and the view. Washington consensus, a set of economic policy recommendations for developing countries, and latin america in particular, that became popular during the 1980s. Finding the right path, finance and development, september. Policy complementarity refers to the mutually reinforcing benefits of policies that create.
But the way he describes the approach conforms in many respects with thomas kuhnos notion of one. The introduction of the washington consensus involved not simply a swing from. The rise and fall of the washington consensus as a. Mar 07, 2011 the 30year record of the washington consensus was abysmal for latin america, which grew less than 1% per year in per capita terms during the period, in contrast with 2. Washington consensus policies evolved over time, both in washington and among latin american policymakers. The rise and fall of the washington consensus as a paradigm. The term washington consensus usually refers to the level of agreement between the international monetary fund imf, world bank, and u. In addition to financial resources, the bank is determined to harness the incredible power of new information technologies, and a new spirit of openness and partnership, to make knowledge of global bestpractice in development accessible to all. The washington consensus is a set of ten economic policy prescriptions considered to constitute the standard reform package promoted for crisiswracked developing countries by washington, d. The ten commandments of the washington consensus balance of. The first written usage was in my background paper for a conference that the institute for international economics convened in order to examine the extent to which the old ideas of development economics that had governed latin american economic policy since the 1950s were.
Diversity in development reconsidering the washington consensus fondad, the hague, december 2004. A short history of the washington consensus john williamson follow this and additional works at. The end of the washington consensus kevin gallagher. Dec 22, 2017 washington consensus definition and criticism 22 december 2017 25 april 2017 by tejvan pettinger the washington consensus refers to a set of broadly free market economic ideas, supported by prominent economists and international organisations, such as the imf, the world bank, the eu and the us. Redefining the role of the state in the interview that follows, professor stiglitz gives his views on a number of important contemporary issues. This preface is brought to you for free and open access by the law journals at smu scholar. The debate on economic policy has developed significantly in the past decade.
The washington consensus versus the beijing consensus. However, the fact that the post washington consensus builds on market reform and includes various other elements ignored by the washington consensus like institutional reform and good governance which are elements that extend the goals of the new consensus and enable it to promote sustainable, egalitarian, and democratic development. Tracing the life of the consensus from a latin american perspective in terms of evolving economic development paradigms, they document the extensive implementation of. The 2002 monterrey consensus, the 2002 johannesburg world summit on sustainable development, and the creation of the new partnership for africas development nepad a year earlier are deliberate attempts to change the donorrecipient relationship from aid as welfare to aid through partnerships. Old washington consensus new washington consensus presumptive. The authors analyze the washington consensus, which at its original formulation reflected views not only from washington, but also from latin america. The term was first used in 1989 by english economist john williamson. The new mantra from the washington consensus mark 2 is 8 the 19751989 growth rates are calculated from table 1. Economic fluctuations and growth program, international finance and macroeconomics program, international trade and investment program. Policy complementarities and the washington consensus. A latin american perspective fifteen years later article pdf available in journal of post keynesian economics 272. By the washington consensus i mean, of course, the oversimplified rendition of. Too much or too little government regulation or market, too poor governance, too little public spending on health and education diagnostic. This means that developing countries should take steps to reduce fiscal deficit.
This analysis leads to the conclusion that washington consensus no longer prevails as an elite northern consensus, and we are presently not only in a period of debate, but in the midst of a. The postwashington consensus development after the crisis nancy birdsall and francis fukuyama the last time a global depression originated in the united states, the impact was devastating not only for the world economy but for world politics as well. This paper argues that there is a substantial body of economic advice, roughly summarized in the washington consensus, that deserves to. This analysis leads to the conclusion that washington consensus no longer prevails as an elite northern consensus, and we are presently not only in a. Washington consensus harvards growth lab harvard university. Nevertheless there are grounds for believing that the impact of the washington consensus on the region has been less positivesum than might be. Nevertheless there are grounds for believing that the impact of the washington consensus on the region has been less positivesum than might be indicated by the possibly special case of argentina. The views and interpretations expressed in this section are those of the author. This approach is often referred to as the beijing consensus bc as compared to the washington consensus wc. Of course, development was the main objective of the. Nazrul islam and his colleagues at undesa for their helpful comments on previous versions of this paper. In sharp contrast with the old paradigm, the new one proclaimed that. Washington consensus, a potential corrective for the somewhat onedimensional and heavily criticised washington consensus. The return of an old familiar ghost washington consensus economies to improve their growth rates has been attacked by economic historians and economists from all corners.
The washington consensus as policy prescription for. One of the central features of the old, precrisis economic consensus was the. The phrase beijing consensus was coined by joshua cooper ramo to frame chinas economic development model as an alternativeespecially for developing countriesto the washington consensus of marketfriendly policies promoted by the imf, world bank, and u. A short history of the washington consensus john williamson senior fellow, institute for international economics paper commissioned by fundacion cidob for a conference from the washington consensus towards a new global governance, barcelona, september 2425, 2004. Redefining the role of the state columbia business school. The developing world needs more globalization, but reforms must be adapted to the political and economic context of each country in order to minimize the costs and to eliminate the roots of the political backlash. Washington consensus the term washington consensus was coined by john williamson 1990 to encapsulate the set of policy reforms advocated with a reasonable degree of consensus by international. This report examines the precise nature of the required institutional reforms needed to achieve higher sustained rates of growth and to make a dent in poverty reduction and provides a framework for their design and implementation.
Other omissions were recognized as such with the passage of time. The postwashington consensus, the role of the state and. The ten commandments of the washington consensus 1. The post washington consensus thesis, launched in 1998 by joseph stiglitz, is the most ambitious attempt to resolve the washington consensus problems, from within mainstream economics.
The washington consensus is a set of ten economic policy prescriptions considered to. That neoliberal model, dubbed by john williamson as the washington consensus, turned out to be more harmful than helpful to the countries that received loans from the. This was in the context of a region where almost all the countries had run large deficits that led to balance of payments crises and high inflation that hit mainly the poor because the rich could park their money abroad. It is time to retire once and for all that tired old phrase of the socalled washington consensus. From the washington consensus towards a new global governance 3 narcis serra, shari spiegel, and joseph e. They control voting power and they overwhelm the decisionmaking. The present term paper is an attempt to explore and put forth the theoretical exposition of the two major development paradigms the marketoriented and the statecummarket centric development models, plausibly portrayed in terms of what is often phrased as the washington consensus and the postwashington consensus. The washington consensus did not necessarily reject the use of social policy, but its focus on efficiency and fiscal discipline often led to cuts in social spending.
448 729 1028 898 1190 1555 686 611 405 1321 1139 167 330 466 879 620 393 1427 391 894 672 198 370 1374 1605 1196 370 854 810 1456 1117 974 1477 1341 1076 51 632 1389 734 1037